When it comes to open source software I’m in the middle of the road. I can’t make a strong case for either side. Well, I can argue each side, but I don’t feel overwhelmingly passionate either way. Just the other day the International Intellectual Property Alliance requested that the US Trade Representative place countries that use open source on the “Special 301 watchlist” The “Special 301 watchlist” is an annual list “examines in detail the adequacy and effectiveness of intellectual property rights”. So basically the report puts together a list different countries that they think should be monitored due to propriety rights or their threat to the free market.
So apparently Indonesia is being put on this list because they are thinking about switching to open source software for their government to run on. The positives to this is that it cuts down on copy write violations from software like Microsoft and it cuts down on spending. Critics claim that it will create unequal market access for software companies (because who wants to buy $700 software when your government is utilizing a free version?). The capitalist in me sympathizes with this point, but the ultimately my desire for choice out ways this. The free market is really the right to choose. If open source software is that choice then great, but I can’t help draw on knock-off bags when I think of OSS. Don’t they have the pitfalls?
Isn’t open source software just a watered down knock off of the original? Sure, you aren’t paying 2,000 for the Louie Vuitton handbag and you’re not paying 700 for Adobe Suite, but are your knockoffs going to do the job? In my experience they don’t. That open source software, pirated/cracked version (I know open source and cracked versions are not the same thing, but I find that if you have one you usually have the other), or knock off bag is going to crash or tear and you aren’t going to be able to fix it. There is not a nice warranty to trade it in to or a “knowledgeable” customer service number to call (hey, its better than nothing). So in the end you are left with some free software that doesn’t do the job and a fake, ripped bag that you got on Canal street for 40 bucks. The quality is lowered, and in the end is it worth it? It is probably just easier to put the money out.
This is all very theoretical of course because I don’t see any time in the near future where I am going to be able to buy the real thing, so open source is going to have to suffice.












